Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Mud Street Muffins

If you have company coming for Thanksgiving weekend, you're probably planning your meals and want to make some extra special recipes to spoil them. I have just the recipe, from Mud Street Cafe at Eureka Springs, they share their famous Mud Street Muffins with us! It's unique, just like everything on their menu... in fact they are winners of Arkansas Readers' Choice Award for their adventuresome breakfasts and delicious desserts.

Located in  what the locals call "Underground Eureka," the building was built in 1888. At that time it was street level but frequent rains would cause the property to flood so eventually the street was built up, putting their present location down a flight of stairs. It's a beautiful building with wonderful old limestone walls, large wooden beams and stained glass lighting.The centerpiece of the dining room is a turn of the century oak bar with beveled mirrors. They feature Eureka's unique local art on the walls, it's a great place to go if you are anywhere near NW Arkansas!

The muffins can be prepared with any kind of fruit you like, fresh or frozen. The crumb topping is to die for, and you can even customize with balsamic vinegar, juices, ginger or nuts if that's to your liking! Mud Street is known for it's innovative dishes and this one is definitely "gourmet!"

The Mud Street Muffin  Just click the title to print!
Preheat oven to 400° for regular oven or 350° for convection oven. Spray 12 cup regular muffin pan or 6 cup large muffin pan.

Crumb Topping
Add to food processor:
1 cup flour
1/2 cup white sugar
1/2 cup powdered sugar
1/2 teaspoon salt
Process ingredients with enough soft butter to form heavy crumbs and set aside.
Dry Ingredients
Sift together in large bowl:
2 generous cups flour
1½ teaspoons baking powder
1 teaspoon baking soda
3/4 teaspoon salt
Any spices being used
(see note below)

Wet Ingredients
Have prepared 2 cups fruit, fresh or frozen
(see note below)
In a 2 cup measuring cup add:
1 Tablespoon any kind of vinegar (balsamic is wonderful!)
2 teaspoons vanilla and any other flavorings to be used (see note below)
Fill to 1 and 1/3 cups with milk and microwave for 45 seconds. In a separate container melt 1/2 cup of butter in microwave. Beat 1 egg into liquid ingredients and add melted butter and beat in.

Add and combine fruit (and nuts to taste if using)to flour mixture, make well in center and add liquid mixture & fold in gently. DO NOT OVERMIX - this will toughen the muffins. Divide batter evenly among muffin cups. If using nuts in the muffins sprinkle same on top of batter in cups. Sprinkle generously with crumb topping. Bake for 26 minutes then test for doneness. Muffins should be firm to the touch. (May take as much as 5 min. more baking time) Let muffins sit in pan on cooling rack for at least 15 minutes before attempting to remove. (longer is better) Use table knife to help lift muffins from pan.

Any kind of fruit can be used. Cut up into pieces about the size of 1/2 inch of your forefinger. Try different combinations of fruit. If using frozen fruit, do not thaw before hand. Frozen fruit like peaches, blackberries, mangos need to be cut into pieces as above. There are all kinds of fruit flavorings available. Add a teaspoon to liquid ingredients to match fruit in muffins. Use fruit juice to replace part or all of milk. If using acidic juice like orange or pineapple (with pineapple tidbits for fruit) then omit the vinegar altogether. Add orange or lemon zest to dry ingredients. If you want lemon muffins replace vinegar with 2 Tablespoons of lemon juice and add a Tablespoon of lemon flavor. Be creative with spice combinations. Use fresh ginger finely chopped. Experiment!! Have fun!!! no matter what you do, the results will be, at the very least, "interesting"; and at best sublime!


  1. The muffins sound delicious. But, the restaurant, Oh my, what a charming place.

    1. I LOVE Eureka! It's only 25 miles from us so we go often!

  2. Npw Joy! Just when I thought my menu was complete, you have peaked my interest!! Have you made these before? Do you recommend I make these for Thanksgiving company? They sound so interesting with the balsamic added?

    1. Sorry I added one.more.thing to your grocery list, but these are company-worthy!

  3. Thank you!! This cafe is lovely!! I haven't been to Eureka Springs in YEARS and YEARS!!
    If and when I visit there again I want to go to Mud Street Cafe!!!

    1. Eureka Springs has so much to offer, and great food is definitely one of their strong suits!

  4. These sound absolutely fabulous. I will have to try to make some. Maybe this weekend.
    Nothing like finding a great bakery/shop.

  5. Recipes like this are not helping me with my weight loss program.....I am saving it for my daughter.

    The do sound delicious...I have blueberries, strawberries, peaches, blackberries, and apples in the freezer. Hmmmm...............

    1. Glenda, make the muffins and freeze all but two. That's my little secret so I portion control, otherwise I can eat the whole batch!


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...